Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Tossed Salad
Chicken Salad
Pepperoni Breadsticks
Plain Bread Sticks
About
Carlos Pizza Columbus
Welcome to Carlos Pizza Columbus, your go-to destination for delicious, hearty pizza in the heart of Columbus, Indiana! Nestled at 2314 25th St, this charming eatery has been a local favorite for over two decades, delighting customers with its friendly service and mouthwatering offerings.
Upon stepping into Carlos Pizza, you're instantly greeted by a warm atmosphere, where the aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air. The staff here goes above and beyond, creating a welcoming environment that keeps patrons returning. As one long-time customer, Arturo Varilla, aptly points out, "Always delicious and the staff is super friendly." It's this combination of great food and exceptional service that truly sets Carlos Pizza apart.
When it comes to the menu, the selection is both diverse and satisfying. Whether you fancy a large slice of classic cheese or want to try their pepperoni-stuffed breadsticks, there’s something for everyone. Jacob Frost recommends the cheese pizza as a must-try, while Donmichael Thompson enjoyed an impressive meal of a slice, two stuffed breadsticks, and a drink for only $8.50—showcasing both quality and value.
If you're looking for comfort food that brings back nostalgic memories, Bri Hutson's experience sums it up well: "I've been coming here since I've been in middle school." The spinach roll and pepperoni breadsticks are fan favorites, and it's clear that Carlos Pizza has become an integral part of many lives.
On my visit, I couldn’t help but notice the clean environment and peaceful ambience, which speaks volumes about their attention to detail. The value here is unbeatable; Joe S shared that "Two of us ate for what it normally costs one of us to have lunch." This highlights the affordability without compromising on taste, making it a perfect spot for families and friends alike.
In conclusion, Carlos Pizza Columbus offers more than just a meal; it provides an experience that speaks to both the palate and the heart. With its delicious offerings, welcoming staff, and a long-standing reputation, it’s no wonder this eatery continues to be a beloved staple in the community. Don’t just take my word for it; come and enjoy a slice of happiness yourself!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Been going here for 20 years. Always delicious and the staff is super friendly. Pizza by the slice. Big slices !! ”
“ Good pizza at a fair price. I would recommend the cheese. ”
“ First time here and will definitely return. Great selection and value for the price. 8.50 got a slice, two pepperoni-stuffed breadsticks, and a drink. ”
“ I've been comming here since I've been in middle school and been getting the same thing, a spinach roll, 2 pepperoni breadsticks and a Pepsi. And every time I come in hes always so nice and polite and evens remembers my order, Carlos pizza is and always will be my favorite pizza spot ”
“ First visit and it was amazing! Super friendly, helpful staff, clean restaurant, delicious food! The best part was the price. Two of us ate for what it normally costs one of us to have lunch. I can’t wait to explore the menu and become a regular patron. ”
“ The food was amazing as always. The staff are always so friendly as well. Best place for a lunch date. ”
“ As a transplanted New Yorker enjoying the many blessings of living in Columbus, I can say if you want genuine New York style pizza with the thin, crispy crust and just the right amount of mozzarella, this is the place. Excellent pizza! ”
“ Everything about this place is amazing. Great pizza, excellent service, and getting your food is fast. Would highly recommend ”